Creative writing workshop critique

Read the piece through the first time as a pure consumer, for interest and hopefully enjoyment. Already answered Not a question Bad question Other. Re-read any difficult passages and, if you have time, the entire manuscript. New entry Dec Preparing an outline of what you intend to cover will help you establish and maintain control of the workshop, even when you don't "lead" it.

To avoid comments that are too harsh or too soft, show your students that you are both respectfully and critically engaged with student work, and they will respond in kind. If you're critiquing the manuscript electronically, you can do a "Save As" on the marked-up manuscript, accept the marked-up changes on the new copy, and then save it with a different but related name from the original manuscript, such as "ManuscriptCleanCopy.

Check out the site for news and such. Sources and Citations http: Some use them more frequently early in the term, when student writers are most in need of instruction, and then taper off as the term goes on. The first explains how and why engaging students in writing workshops facilitates learning; the second offers several methods for teaching students how to respond to their peers' writing; the third offers strategies for diagnosis and response that you can model in the writing workshops.

The following steps offer direction in how to critique creative writing for others. The instructor must therefore facilitate rather than direct the discussion. Workshops can be an invaluable resource to writers as they are a great way to get feedback and suggestions on their manuscripts, as well as providing a social forum for interaction with other writers.

For instance, if you want students to practice the Common Reader method, take the time to walk them through that method and explain to them what you expect them to gain.

Point out the author's strengths, with specific examples, such as "I liked the details in your characters, you gave your heroine the same middle name as her mother, in addition to describing her as being a dead ringer for her mother. Questions that come up as someone presents a critique may be best saved until the critic finishes if the participant is doing so for the first time or appears nervous when speaking. Usually, writers who can't handle feedback aren't willing to put their work out for critiquing.

You can ask them to expand on points they raise, but not make points for them. Very Happy minion — last donation was today. Now I'm going to cover a daunting challenge in creating comics Check out Books by Critters for books by your fellow Critterfolk, as well as my list of recommended books for writers. Most instructors hold them the day a first draft is due, in order to facilitate the revision process. If you've been running your workshops successfully, students will be eager to volunteer—they'll have seen how helpful the process is and will want the "leg up" that an in-class critique can offer.

For example, "Your description of the castle was perfect, I felt like I was there. What are the Critique. Watch this space for ebook and print editions of all of Advent's current titles! Include your email address to get a message when this question is answered.

If the writer is looking for help with spelling, punctuation, and grammar, provide that to the best of your ability. Readers tend to be harder on a text when they don't know who wrote it.

That will let the writer know whether to dismiss your comments or to look for a critique from another person more familiar with the genre or writing style. Insist that students be respectfully and critically engaged with the paper.

As with describing the strengths, provide specifics in a positive way. What else did I need to know? If you do, you can ask students to take a moment and jot down their responses. There might be bits of downtime as your boxes learn new addresses and things. The more thorough your feedback, the more effectively you present it to the writer, the easier and more likely he or she will be to make the corrections in future revisions.

However, if you've never critiqued student papers in class, you will discover that talking about student writing differs in some important ways from talking about the other readings in your class.

Writing workshops provide a way for writers to learn from one another, by giving and receiving feedback on plot, characterization, and writing style. If the thesis is muddled, suggest alternatives. Generally, you won't encounter students who are out to hurt one another during peer critiques. By modelling the form of critique you want participants to use, you in turn encourage them to model it. Decide on the critiquing method you want to use and practice it. Some instructors who use Collaborative Learning methods like peer editing groups see the writing workshop as a way of modeling peer critique strategies for their students.

Let me know if you find anything that isn't working right. But we've found several advantages to "outing" the writer, among them:. This second effort really requires critical thinking. Start by reading Critiquing the Wild Writer: In these workshops, instructors use student papers in part or in whole as the basis of discussion and instruction. Why or why not? What is the pace of the piece, and why? All genres of writing By using this service, some information may be shared with YouTube.

Don't focus on style, look at the mechanics of the work. You're reading the text for content, consistency, grammar, punctuation, and style. There may be times when a writer doesn't really know what kind of critique they want or need.